Steady in the Wind: The Benefits of Consistency

In recent articles, I’ve been dealing with the question: Is it better for a leader to be flexible or to be consistent?

I think the answer is: There’s a time and a place for each. A simple answer on paper, of course, but not so simple in practice.

I’ve described some of the reasons why flexibility is a hallmark of the practice of leadership for the YES! Leader. I’ve also noted some of boundaries that must be placed on the YES! Leader’s flexibility. Today I’d like to address the question: What are some of the benefits of consistency?

I think there are at least three areas in which consistent behavior by a leader is not only beneficial but essential:

1) Predictability and Safety. Each of us has probably worked for someone with an erratic personality. He might come through the door in a calm, laid-back mood one day, screaming and yelling the next.  He may respond to a critical situation in a level-headed manner, then be set off by a small issue. You never know exactly “who” this person will be at any given time. This kind of leader creates an unsafe environment which often causes people to withhold or parcel out information for fear of the reaction it might provoke.  A leader must keep control of his emotions and reactions in order to maintain a consistent demeanor upon which others can rely.

2) Trust. In order to build trust with others, a leader needs to send a consistent message. If she communicates conflicting opinions and factual characterizations to different people at different times, or if she fails to follow through on what she says she will do, then she will quickly undermine her credibility.

Of course, consistency isn’t a matter of saying “That’s my story and I’m sticking to it” – no matter what. There may be times when she recognizes the need to vary from a previous message – say, because she learns new information that indicates the need for a course change.  In that case, she must openly and honestly acknowledge the variance, explain the reasons behind the change, and admit to any mistakes on her part.

3) Decision-Making. An effective leader must have a reliable internal compass – a sense of True North, as the author Bill George puts it – in order to provide an underlying coherence to his decisions and actions. If he seems to bend with the prevailing winds when it comes to making decisions or forming opinions (a syndrome known in the political world as “flip-flopping”), then people will quickly question whether he can be depended upon to keep a steady hand on the wheel. (And - to carry the metaphor one step further – they may well ask: Can his actions and decisions provide calm in any storm that might be encountered?)

Consistency doesn’t mean rigidly applying a set of simple rules in a black-and-white manner. Instead, it means possessing (and living) a firm set of values and principles that serve as a guideline to dealing with the sometimes gray areas of life.

REFLECTIONS FOR THE YES! LEADER

I’ve observed the ways in which flexibility is important for the YES! Leader. But consider the following:

·         Are you so flexible that you keep people off guard, not quite sure from minute to minute “who” you are – or how they should interact with you?

·         Do you sense that people are being less than totally open with you for fear of how you’ll react?

·         Are you trying so hard to be everything to everybody that nobody can take what you say at face value?

·         Can you point to a set of personal core values that guide your day-to-day (and even moment-to-moment) decisions and actions?